The Commonwealth is 60 years old this year, though one can be forgiven for not having noticed. This 53 nation club appears to be marking the occasion with just enough fanfare to justify its existence, while simultaneously attempting not to draw too much attention to itself, lest awkward questions are asked of its purpose in the modern world. Sixty years on from the London Declaration that marked the birth of the modern Commonwealth, it is now fitting to shine the spotlight on the workings of this organisation, to ask whether it can achieve its aims and objectives, and to question whether it can live up to the principles its members have pledged to embrace.
On 1 September this year, Commonwealth Secretary-General Kamalesh Sharma announced ‘with deep regret’ that Fiji was suspended from the association. With no indication that Fiji was ready to comply with the terms set out by the Commonwealth Ministerial Action Group in July 2009 to restore democracy following the 2006 coup, this was not an unexpected move. After all, one of the guiding principles of the Commonwealth is the supremacy of democracy, and any member found not to abide by these principles can expect censure.
But this is not always the case. While Fiji may miss out on taking part in Commonwealth sporting events and attending intergovernmental Commonwealth meetings (something that Tony Blair reportedly said in 2002 he would rather be at home watching football than doing), another member of the Commonwealth family appears to be able to flout its guiding principles with impunity. Sri Lanka’s 26 year civil war was declared over in May this year, amidst widespread celebrations within the country’s Sinhalese majority, but the steady trickle of information in the form of eye-witness testimony and video evidence emerging from the war-torn region of the rebels’ last stand is raising serious questions as to the conduct of the Sri Lankan military and the nature of the Sri Lankan government itself.
The Commonwealth cannot argue that the issues currently affecting Sri Lanka do not fall within its remit. On conflict prevention and mediation the Commonwealth asserts ‘The Secretariat’s objective is to prevent and resolve conflict while also strengthening the ability of member countries to promote our fundamental values.’ The Commonwealth has however remained silent as thousands of Tamil civilians were killed during army shelling in the last weeks of the war and stood idly by as scores of Tamils have ‘disappeared’ both during and after the fighting. Conflict mediation this is not. On human rights the Commonwealth declares ‘The Secretariat aims to increase awareness of and respect for human rights in the Commonwealth’. At the time of writing, up to 300 000 Tamils remain interned in camps, one third of under-fives reportedly suffering malnutrition. The Sri Lankan government state that they have arrested at least 10000 suspects, although the International Committee of the Red Cross has access to only 2000. These suspects have no access to legal support and next to no hope of a fair trial. While Minister for Disaster Management and Human Rights Mahinda Samarasinghe assures UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-Moon that the Sri Lankan government of President Mahinda Rajapaksa is committed to resettling the Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs), it seems certain that this process is set to drag on much longer than the six months promised by the Sri Lankan government back in May.
Freedom of speech, a vital pillar of democracy, has also been compromised. Journalists have been murdered and intimidated, and the courts have been politicised, giving the government a stick with which to beat those who have the nerve to speak out. The journalist J. S. Tissainayagan was sentenced to 20 years hard labour in August for criticising army tactics, a fate President Obama declared was ‘emblematic of the hundreds of journalists who face intimidation, censorship and arbitrary arrest’. It is not only Obama who has criticised the Sri Lankan government. Amnesty International have criticised not only the conduct of the war but also the government’s denial of basic human rights including freedom of movement to civilians in the internment camps, and the EU has stated that ‘Sri Lanka has failed to honour important human-rights commitments.’ Human Rights Watch has reasserted the need for an international commission of inquiry into possible war crimes following the video obtained by ‘Journalists for Democracy’ showing alleged executions of naked and bound Tamils by government soldiers. The Sri Lankan government has claimed the video is a fake and has threatened legal action against Channel 4 for airing the video, though UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-Moon has discussed the implications of the images with the human rights minister, and the US ambassador to the UN has expressed ‘grave concern.’
So why has the Commonwealth apparently turned a blind eye to the ongoing crisis in Sri Lanka? One problem is that the organisation has no clear role and mission. For all its (no doubt well-intentioned) public utterances and assertions on human rights, democracy and the rule of law, the Commonwealth has few real powers, and therefore has little influence. The Commonwealth does not coordinate foreign or defence policy, and lacks the budget and authority to make a real difference in the world. There is nothing in the way of trade privileges for members that could be seen as adding purpose to the organisation. Self-interest will always take precedence over commonwealth solidarity, and it is more convenient for countries such as Britain to express mild concern over events in Sri Lanka and be thankful that the war is over than to ask awkward questions, especially when the British government has itself waged divisive wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. This does however mean that the Commonwealth all too frequently fails to practice what it preaches and takes the path of least resistance, only taking uncontroversial decisions leading to inconsequential outcomes.
The Commonwealth covers 2 billion people around the world, and to mark 60 years since the London Declaration, the Royal Commonwealth Society in London is ‘facilitating the largest global dialogue ever undertaken between peoples of the Commonwealth about their association.’ To the question ‘Do you think the Commonwealth is still relevant?’, at the time of writing only 35% have answered in the affirmative, but much more telling is the number of votes cast, just 743. It is also to be noted that 81% of respondents associate the Commonwealth with empire. This feeds into the widespread impression that the Commonwealth is an anachronism, an echo of a bygone age, and increasingly superfluous in the modern world.
The Commonwealth prides itself on being a values-based organisation and a forum for dialogue, and no doubt it has proved useful, arguably in no small part for Britain in easing the decline from imperial overlord to mid-ranking European power. However, it needs to stop appearing to wear its weakness as a badge of honour. Events in Sri Lanka should serve to highlight the impotence of the Commonwealth in its current guise, and to expose as hollow its assertions on standing up for the principles on which it is based. The fact that the Commonwealth appears unwilling, unable, or more likely both to get its hands dirty in Sri Lanka, is symptomatic of the impotence which feeds the organisation’s inertia. When Commonwealth leaders meet in Trinidad and Tobago in November, it should not this time be to hammer out a justification for meeting again in two years time. It should be to reassess its aims and objectives and how it will realise them, and to find a viable way to adapt to meet the challenges facing the world of today. Failure to do so will only make it increasingly unlikely that the association will be celebrating anything 60 years hence.
Showing posts with label Commonwealth. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Commonwealth. Show all posts
Monday, 5 October 2009
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
